Skip to content

24x7Service 24 hours a day, 7 days a week24-hour service

Multicanal
Collections & Relationship

Ethical collections: what Brazil’s Consumer Protection Code forbids in arts. 42 and 71

Embarrassing, threatening or exposing debtors is not just bad practice: it can lead to double refunds and even criminal charges. See what the CDC forbids.

Multicanal Content Team 3 min read

Ethical collections: what Brazil's Consumer Protection Code forbids in arts. 42 and 71
Foto: aqua.mech (Flickr), licença CC BY 2.0 — imagem adaptada pela Multicanal.

Collecting is legitimate; embarrassing people is not. Brazil’s Consumer Protection Code (Código de Defesa do Consumidor, Law 8,078/1990) draws a clear line between recovering credit and humiliating the debtor, and crossing it exposes companies to damages, double refunds and even criminal prosecution. For a collections operation, knowing this line is as important as hitting targets.

Art. 42: no ridicule, embarrassment or threats

Art. 42 states that, when collecting debts, the defaulting consumer shall not be exposed to ridicule or subjected to any kind of embarrassment or threat. Its sole paragraph adds a direct financial consequence: whoever collects an undue amount must refund twice what the consumer overpaid, with monetary adjustment and legal interest, unless the error was justifiable.

Art. 42-A, added in 2009, requires every collection document presented to the consumer to show the name, address and CPF or CNPJ (Brazilian taxpayer numbers) of the supplier of the product or service. Debtors must know clearly who is collecting and for what.

Art. 71: when abusive collection becomes a crime

Art. 71 makes it a crime to use, in debt collection, threats, coercion, physical or moral embarrassment, false, incorrect or misleading statements or any other procedure that unjustifiably exposes the consumer to ridicule or interferes with their work, rest or leisure. The penalty is three months to one year of detention plus a fine.

In a contact center operation, this translates into very concrete prohibited conduct:

  • threatening consequences that do not exist or will not be applied, such as jail;
  • giving false or inaccurate amounts, charges or deadlines;
  • exposing the debt to coworkers, neighbors, relatives or on social media;
  • insisting on contacts that interfere with work, rest or leisure, such as repeated calls or calls at inappropriate times;
  • using an intimidating tone, irony or humiliating language.

How to build ethical and effective collections

Ethics and results are not opposites: a negotiation that preserves the customer’s dignity opens the way to agreements that hold. Some pillars:

  • scripts reviewed by the legal team, with clear language and no threats;
  • checking amounts and charges before each contact to avoid undue collection;
  • identifying the creditor in every message and document;
  • a policy on contact frequency and hours, with a record of every attempt;
  • quality monitoring and a channel for customers to dispute the debt;
  • data processing in line with the LGPD, Brazil’s data protection law, without exposing the debt to third parties.
2xdouble refund of amounts unduly collected
Art. 71abusive collection can be a crime
1 yearmaximum detention penalty (art. 71)
💡 Did you know?

The CDC was signed into law on September 11, 1990, but only took effect in March 1991: the text itself (art. 118) set a 180-day period after publication before it came into force.

References and legislation

  • Lei 8.078/1990 (CDC) · arts. 42, 42-A and 71, debt collection — access
  • Lei 14.181/2021 · Over-indebtedness Law, which amended the CDC — access
  • Lei 13.709/2018 (LGPD) · Brazil’s General Personal Data Protection Law — access
✍️ Expert note

In collections, every call is also a relationship call. We train teams to tell firmness from pressure: inform clearly, offer negotiation options and record everything. This protects the customer, the creditor and the agent.

— Multicanal Content Team · Multicanal Contact Center

How Multicanal helps: when contracted, our collections and negotiation operations follow reviewed scripts, quality monitoring and call recording, focused on sustainable agreements.

Discover our collections
Collections & Relationship

Keep reading

Let’s talk

Your service operation, designed for your audience — 24 hours a day.

Contact our sales team through the official intranet channel and receive a tracking number. We also handle requests for our policies, manuals and management-system practices.